Back when I started in early 2010, I accidentally rolled on an US server instead of an EU one. My entire playtime got shuffled up because of wrong timezones, but the server was so good that I did not feel like re-rolling on an EU server again. That server was Elendilmir.
The loss is going to be great, but to be really fair, most of the folks who made this server what it was, so many different communities/etc, have been gone for a long time as well.
Here's to the old memories and hopefully some new ones on the surviving servers.